The finished white gold and diamond anniversary ring, created by Jeffrey’s Jewelry Design Studio for Margot and Paul Hightower’s 25th wedding anniversary.

The finished white gold and diamond anniversary ring, created by Jeffrey’s Jewelry Design Studio for Margot and Paul Hightower’s 25th wedding anniversary.

One-of-a-kind jewelry is easier – and more affordable – than you might think!

Couple gets creative with local artisans to mark silver anniversary in gold

As Margot and Paul Hightower approached their 25th wedding anniversary, Margot knew she wanted something special to mark the milestone.

She loved her wedding ring and wanted to add a complementary piece; in fact, she already had a design in mind when she first visited Jeffrey’s Jewelry Design Studio in Federal Way.

What happened next yielded more than a few pleasant surprises!

“Jeffrey’s” is actually the skilled team of master goldsmith Jeffrey Buetow and skilled jewelry designer John Profit. The two share decades of collective experience in all aspects of the industry, and together have elevated the level of jewelry design, creating both brand new jewelry and remarkable transformations from existing pieces.

“I had been going to Jeffrey’s for a really long time, so I knew they were very friendly and knowledgeable,” Margot says.

What she wasn’t as prepared for was how easy and affordable the process was…

More affordable than expected: By using a consignment wedding set from the store, the Hightowers saved one-third to one-half of the cost of creating the ring from new materials, she says. “I already had a design in mind and we visited a few times until we found the perfect set to work with. With John we were able to take an already beautiful piece of jewelry and re-create it into something new and meaningful to us.”

Design expertise created the perfect piece: While Margo already had an idea of what she wanted, Jeffrey and John listened to her goals and with their decades of design knowledge, created a ring that was even better than she hoped. In re-imagining the original wedding set, Margot initially envisioned a curving white gold band set with a single diamond. Profit suggested incorporating some of the smaller diamonds as well, and through several revisions, created the stunning piece Margot wears today. “They are so open and gave me some amazing ideas I hadn’t considered,” she says. “When we got the wax mold, it as so exciting.”

The process was easy and enjoyable: “I thought the process would be difficult, but it was so fun and creative,” Margot reflects. “John and Jeffrey really do work hard to make it all so simple, and to create the perfect piece. I even have diamonds left from the original ring to create earrings or a necklace!

“After working with Jeffrey’s on our anniversary ring, I couldn’t be happier.”

To learn more, stop by Jeffrey’s Jewelry Design Studio at 1200 S 324th St, in Federal Way or visit online at

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Marketplace

Dr. Scott Trapman is accepting new patients at the Pacific Medical Centers (PacMed) Federal Way at 31833 Gateway Center Blvd S. (Photo: A. Michael Cole)
There’s no quick fix to quit smoking, but this family doctor still wants to help

Former military doctor now treats Federal Way patients of all ages, helping them stay healthy

Jodi Longley, from CMG Financial
Smart solutions for savvy homeowners

All In One option re-thinks traditional 30-year mortgage

5 reasons to try Eagle Tire and Automotive

From tires to maintenance and repairs, your trusted local source is here

Using acoustic waves to relieve chronic pain

Federal Way chiropractor encouraged by results of recent study

Building resilience into back-to-school planning

CIS Federal Way supports local students in need with supplies and community connections

Healing, growth and community-building for Federal Way’s Black community

FW Black Collective launching new services during online healing event Aug. 21-23

New study: early intervention key to lasting whiplash care

Whiplash pain may resurface years later if left untreated

How the right questions yield smart mortgage solutions

New mortgage or refinancing, find a trusted source with local knowledge and experience

Innovative approach keeps theater at Centerstage

Federal Way theatre company is excited to share season with actors and audiences

Cooking up delicious ideas to keep your annual events happening safely!

Fundraisers and special events ARE still possible thanks to this innovative team

Got your back: Tech innovations bring patients the highest standard of chiropractic care

From ‘party hats’ to powerful diagnostic technology…what to expect from a visit to the chiropractor

Best Pick Reports features a curated list of professionals, evaluated based on thousands of Seattle-area customer interviews.
For a successful home project, trust a professional guaranteed by Best Pick Reports

Free guide gives Federal Way homeowners a wealth of resources, and peace of mind