A Feb. 27, 2008, article in The Wall Street Journal (“School choice isn’t enough”) featured school reform.

  • Friday, June 13, 2008 7:58pm
  • Opinion

A Feb. 27, 2008, article in The Wall Street Journal (“School choice isn’t enough”) featured school reform.

It pointed out that Catholic schools spend less than public schools and produce a superior product. The reason was belief in coherent content-based curriculum and enforced order in the classroom.

Maybe this success with voucher students would encourage public schools to exchange “progressive education” approaches for the Catholic school method.

Not only vouchers, but also charter schools, tuition tax credits, mayoral control and other reforms are now on the table as alternatives to public school systems. A study of the Milwaukee voucher system showed that low-income students benefited academically using Catholic schools. It was less clear that the presence of choice in the community motivated public schools to improve.

Education scholars are in two camps. The “incentivists” have an outlook that remains dominant within school reform circles. They advocate parent choice, pay incentives, vouchers, charter schools, etc. The second, “instructionists,” believe that curriculum change and good teaching are essential to improving schools.

New York City’s school district has embraced the “incentivist” approach with market incentives (i.e., teacher pay, additional education credits, competition in the public schools and cash incentives). It blithely retained a fuzzy math program and teaching of phonics and phonemic awareness. It promotes choice, markets and accountability and has rejected all responsibility for curriculum and instruction. Improvement is minimal and tastes are dumbed down.

Massachusetts has achieved spectacular academic improvement. It has improved more than every other state in the National Assessment of Education Progress (NAEP) tests. In 2007, it scored first in the nation in fourth- and eighth-grade math and reading. Massachusetts has no vouchers, no tuition tax credits, very few charter schools and no market incentives for principals and teachers. Education leaders were “instructionists” who pushed the state’s board of education to mandate a vigorous curriculum for all grades, created tests linked to the curriculum standards and insisted that all potential high school graduates pass a comprehensive exit exam. Reading instruction in the early grades includes explicit phonics.

A professor of education reform sums it up: “The lesson from Massachusetts is that a strong content-based curriculum, together with upgraded certification regulations and teacher licensure tests that require teacher preparation programs to address that content, can be the best recipe for improving students’ academic achievement.”

The Federal Way School District introduced phonics years ago, accompanied by teacher training, and has accomplished success in WASL tests. However, fuzzy math persists as a result of teaching conceptual math vs. numerical math. New textbooks did not improve WASL scores for lower-half students.

I trust our state school board and Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction will adopt “instructionist” reform. Incentivist and progressive education programs have been less than successful.

There is little hope of school reform so long as the college and non-college elite and public school establishment continue their course of not providing bottom-half students with proper curriculum and instruction.

John Hoskinson is a Federal Way resident.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@federalwaymirror.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.federalwaymirror.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Opinion

Opinion: Public deserves honest information on sex education

The Washington comprehensive sex education bill passed in the Senate on March 7.

Grocery store staff are working hard to keep the shelves stocked during the COVID-19 pandemic. File photo
Thank you grocery store clerks

Recognizing the sacrifices of our unsung essential workforce.

Federal Way trapped in a ‘Catch 22’

We are mediocre in a region that is rapidly becoming global, educated and economically relevant. We have a mountain to climb.

State of the City

Elections are next year, and with the high profile marketing for the event, the speech always sounds more like a “please vote for me” campaign kick-off.

Welcome to Olympia Mr. Johnson

Sometimes making a law isn’t pretty, and by the time everybody weighs in, that great idea may look completely different.

Mirror’s role in vetting Federal Way Council candidates

The Mirror conducted a background check on all 19 candidates who applied for the Pos. 2 vacancy.

19 want to join Federal Way City Council

The six remaining council members will decide who the new council member will be, and politics will play a role.

South King Fire and Rescue needs to think of public transparency

The “old boy’s club” that is our fire department doesn’t appear all that interested in having the taxpayers, who pay the bill, actually understand what is going.

Exploring Federal Way as a new frontier

Overcoming Federal Way’s general apathy toward exploring itself as a new frontier is essential for shedding the effects of being a hollowed-out corporate company town.

Short legislative session turns left

With a progressive agenda including comprehensive sex education, clean fuel standards and gun violence, Democrats will need to be cautious about overreach.

New state legislator reflects on Federal Way service

“My office and email address may have changed, but my values haven’t.”

Mayor’s style divides Federal Way community

Ferrell’s pattern of behavior is dividing the community in such a negative manner he needs to rethink his entire style if he hopes to be an effective leader.